3:08 p.m.
Hi,
I have produce a web form and a captcha script to stop spamming of the form.
The problem I have is that on the captcha page, after the correct text has been entered
the page redirects to another page. A couple of users who have been testing this in
Netsurf (current versions) have said they get a "url redirect error"
I have tested this on my A9home with Netsurf but do not receive any error message I am
therefore asking if anyone on here can test the url below to see if other people receive
the same error message.
http://www.phawfaux.co.uk/ro-connect/devconf/secimagev3.asp
The link above is directly to the captcha image. What should happen is after you have
correctly typed in the text and hit the verify button, the browser will return the text:
"All required fields must be completed"
This also appears to work fine in Internet Explorer 6, Firefox 2 and Opera 9.27.
Regards
--
Paul Stewart - Far Bletchley, Milton Keynes, UK.
Be Bold. Dare To Be Different. Use RISC OS (http://www.riscos.com).
It's blue and from outta town - The A9home
(http://www.advantage6.co.uk/A9hsplash.html).
A9home Compatibility page -
(http://www.phawfaux.co.uk/a9home/compatibility.asp).
3:31 p.m.
On 23 Apr, Paul Stewart wrote:
I am therefore asking if anyone on here can test the url below to
see
if other people receive the same error message.
The link above is directly to the captcha image. What should happen
is after you have correctly typed in the text and hit the verify
button, the browser will return the text: "All required fields must
be completed"
Works here, with NetSurf 2.0 (Dev) (21 Apr 2008 22:15) r4101, on RISC
OS 5.13
--
Brian Howlett
------------------------------------------------------------------
Last year I went fishing with Salvador Dali. He was using a dotted
line. He caught every other fish.
4:44 p.m.
In article <29473.1208941738(a)phawfaux.co.uk>, Paul Stewart
<paulstewart(a)phawfaux.co.uk> wrote:
I have tested this on my A9home with Netsurf but do not receive any
error message I am therefore asking if anyone on here can test the
url below to see if other people receive the same error message.
The link above is directly to the captcha image. What should happen
is after you have correctly typed in the text and hit the verify
button, the browser will return the text: "All required fields must
be completed"
Works OK here with Netsurf r4099
--
Barry A.
7:09 p.m.
In article <29473.1208941738(a)phawfaux.co.uk>, Paul Stewart
<paulstewart(a)phawfaux.co.uk> wrote:
The link above is directly to the captcha image. What should happen
is
after you have correctly typed in the text and hit the verify button, the
browser will return the text: "All required fields must be completed"
As predicted here with Test Build 20th April 07 and 5.11.
John
--
|| John Williams || Brittany, Northern France
Who is John Williams? http://www.picindex.info/author/
E-mail replies only accepted from RISC OS machines or RISC in subject line
Somewhere nice to stay in Brittany? http://petit.four.free.fr/visitors/locate
7:25 p.m.
On Wed, 23 Apr 2008, Paul Stewart wrote:
I have produce a web form and a captcha script to stop spamming of
the form.
Ugh. Why is is that most captchas are a) illegible and b) wholly
inaccessible to the visually impaired? I've never understood what's wrong
with simply asking a question that only a human could answer correctly
(e.g. "What colour is the sky?")
The problem I have is that on the captcha page, after the correct
text
has been entered the page redirects to another page. A couple of users
who have been testing this in Netsurf (current versions) have said they
get a "url redirect error"
Without more details, that's meaningless, I'm afraid. Please ask them to
report the issue on the NetSurf bug tracker, attaching the log file from
the NetSurf session in which the problem was encountered.
John.
7:43 p.m.
John-Mark Bell <jmb(a)netsurf-browser.org> wrote:
On Wed, 23 Apr 2008, Paul Stewart wrote:
> I have produce a web form and a captcha script to stop spamming of the
> form.
Ugh. Why is is that most captchas are a) illegible and
Thats the idea, after all, otherwise a simple bit of OCR would break them.
b) wholly inaccessible to the visually impaired?
Some do have an audio option for such users.
I've never understood what's wrong
with simply asking a question that only a human could answer correctly
(e.g. "What colour is the sky?")
Which could easily be defeated by a speech recognition system. So instead
the text sounds like it is being shouted by someone at the back of a busy
call centre. Its about the same level of difficulty to understand as the
visual version.
One such example is the msn registration (only had a look it was mentioned
in the register register), but not much use for here as NetSurf can't get
to the registration page to try it out.
Cheers
---Dave
--
Email: druck(a)druck.org.uk
Phone: +44- (0)7974 108301
7:56 p.m.
On Wed, 2008-04-23 at 14:43 +0100, David J. Ruck wrote:
John-Mark Bell <jmb(a)netsurf-browser.org> wrote:
> On Wed, 23 Apr 2008, Paul Stewart wrote:
> > I have produce a web form and a captcha script to stop spamming of the
> > form.
>
> Ugh. Why is is that most captchas are a) illegible and
Thats the idea, after all, otherwise a simple bit of OCR would break them.
Research shows that OCR is more effective at reading them than humans
are. Semantic CAPTCHAS are by far the most effective.
B.
8:51 p.m.
Rob Kendrick <rjek(a)netsurf-browser.org> wrote:
Research shows that OCR is more effective at reading them than
humans
are.
Better than a web cafe full of Indians earning $4 a day? :-)
Anyhow better stop this now, way off topic.
Cheers
---Dave
--
Email: druck(a)druck.org.uk
Phone: +44- (0)7974 108301
4:05 a.m.
John-Mark Bell wrote:
Ugh. Why is is that most captchas are a) illegible and b) wholly
inaccessible to the visually impaired? I've never understood what's
wrong with simply asking a question that only a human could answer
correctly (e.g. "What colour is the sky?")
I have the very same problem than Paul for a guestbook on a site I
maintain as well. Spam is increasing now and I have to act.
My solution is a totally naive one and I'm interested to see whether my
reasoning works: I think spam bots fill all text fields present, after
all they want to get their message across, the more the better. I have
now added a text field to the form with the comment "Please leave
empty!" which I enforce.
I did this just today, so have no experience on how good it works. But
I'd be interested to hear what others think, perhaps by private email
because it's getting off-topic here, but as the topic was raised here
... please forgive me.
--
Stefan Bellon
4:31 a.m.
On Wed, 23 Apr 2008, John-Mark Bell wrote:
On Wed, 23 Apr 2008, Paul Stewart wrote:
> The problem I have is that on the captcha page, after the correct text has
> been entered the page redirects to another page. A couple of users who
> have been testing this in Netsurf (current versions) have said they get a
> "url redirect error"
Without more details, that's meaningless, I'm afraid. Please ask them to
report the issue on the NetSurf bug tracker, attaching the log file from the
NetSurf session in which the problem was encountered.
Ok, this has now been reported on the bug tracker with a log file. The
answer is that NetSurf is being less tolerant of junk input than other
browsers. However, the URL you're redirecting to contains spaces. These
should be percent encoded (i.e replaced with %20).
At some point in the relatively near future, I'd expect NetSurf to handle
this case. It's not an entirely trivial fix, however.
John.
4958
days inactive
4966
days old
netsurf-users@netsurf-browser.org
9 comments
8 participants
participants (8)
-
Barry E Allen -
Brian Howlett -
David J. Ruck -
John Williams -
John-Mark Bell -
Paul Stewart -
Rob Kendrick -
Stefan Bellon